Hypermobility In Pilates: Why More Flexibility Is Often The Last Thing Your Client Needs
Pilates attracts a lot of hypermobile clients.
That makes sense.
People who move easily often enjoy movement-based exercise. They may have excellent range, find stretching comfortable and appear to perform advanced positions with very little effort.
From the outside, they can look exceptionally capable.
But range of motion and control are not the same thing.
A client may be able to move their shoulder well beyond average range and still have poor control of the joint.
They may easily drop into a deep split squat yet struggle to stabilise through the hip.
They may have enormous spinal extension but very little strength at end range.
They may "look flexible" while constantly experiencing:
shoulder discomfort
hip pain
lower back sensitivity
knee instability
fatigue
recurring strains
difficulty maintaining control under load
This is why hypermobility requires more than simply admiring range.
For Pilates instructors, one of the most important shifts is understanding that hypermobile clients often need more strength, more control and better load tolerance not more stretching.
What Is Hypermobility?
Joint hypermobility refers to a joint moving beyond what is considered a typical range.
Some people are naturally more mobile because of their anatomy and connective tissue characteristics.
Hypermobility can be localised to one or two joints or present throughout multiple areas of the body.
For some people, it causes no symptoms at all.
For others, it can be associated with:
pain
instability
fatigue
recurrent injuries
poor proprioception
difficulty controlling end range
The key point is this:
Hypermobility itself is not automatically a problem.
The problem arises when available range exceeds the person's ability to control it.
Flexibility And Hypermobility Are Not The Same Thing
These terms are often used interchangeably, but they are different.
Flexibility usually refers to the length of muscles and soft tissues.
Hypermobility refers to the amount of movement available at a joint.
A client can be highly flexible without being globally hypermobile.
Likewise, someone can have hypermobile joints without necessarily having exceptional muscular flexibility everywhere.
This matters because the treatment strategy changes depending on what is actually present.
If a client is flexible because of long muscle length, stretching may still be relevant in some contexts.
If a client is hypermobile and already has excessive joint range, adding more range may not be useful at all.
Why Hypermobile Clients Often Feel "Tight"
This surprises many instructors.
Hypermobile clients can still feel tight.
In fact, they often do.
That does not automatically mean they need stretching.
The sensation of tightness may come from:
muscle guarding
poor control
fatigue
instability
protective tension
high resting muscle activity
In other words, the body may increase muscular tension because the joint itself feels less stable.
The client then interprets that muscular tension as "tightness" and stretches more.
They feel temporary relief.
Then the sensation returns because the underlying control issue remains.
This can create an endless cycle of:
instability → protective tension → stretching → temporary relief → instability remains
Understanding this is crucial.
Why More Stretching Can Be The Wrong Answer
Stretching is not inherently bad.
But for a client who already has more than enough range, repeatedly chasing further flexibility may create more movement than they can control.
That can increase joint stress and reinforce a pattern of relying on passive structures rather than muscular control.
This is especially relevant at areas such as:
shoulders
hips
knees
lumbar spine
elbows
For these clients, the goal is often not to create more range.
It is to build strength and control inside the range they already have.
Hypermobile Shoulders
The shoulder is one of the most common areas where hypermobility shows up.
A hypermobile client may easily reach far overhead or behind the body.
They may appear to have "amazing shoulder mobility."
But look more closely and you may notice:
difficulty controlling the scapula
poor endurance
recurrent shoulder aching
instability in plank positions
collapsing through the front of the joint
fatigue with overhead work
The solution is usually not more mobility.
Instead, programming may prioritise:
rotator cuff strength
serratus anterior
scapular control
gradual overhead loading
controlled weight-bearing
end-range stability
The goal is to create a shoulder that can manage the range available to it.
Locking The Knees In Standing
Another common hypermobility presentation is standing with the knees pushed fully
backwards into hyperextension.
This often happens because the client is using passive joint structures for stability rather than muscular control.
Simply saying:
"Don't lock your knees"
usually isn't enough.
The client may not know what an alternative strategy feels like.
They may also lack the calf, quadriceps or hip strength needed to maintain a more controlled position.
A better approach may involve:
slight knee flexion
controlled standing work
calf strengthening
quadriceps endurance
hip stability
single-leg balance
The goal isn't to create fear around knee extension.
It is to improve control across the available range.
Hypermobile Elbows In Plank
Hypermobile clients often "hang" into elbow extension during:
planks
long stretch
quadruped work
push-ups
This reduces muscular demand and transfers more load into passive joint structures.
Again, simply saying:
"Don't lock your elbows"
may not solve the issue.
Instead, the client may need:
triceps strength
shoulder stability
scapular control
reduced hold times
modified loading
slower progressions
The exercise should be adjusted so the client can maintain active support rather than collapsing into end range.
Excessive Lumbar Extension
Hypermobile clients often appear to have excellent spinal extension.
They can move into large ranges effortlessly.
But more range is not always better.
A client with excessive lumbar extension may rely on that range whenever other areas cannot contribute.
For example, during overhead arm work they may gain movement by extending through the lumbar spine.
During prone work they may repeatedly collapse into the lower back rather than creating true thoracic extension or hip extension.
Programming should therefore focus on:
trunk control
hip extension
thoracic mobility
ribcage positioning
anti-extension strength
Again, the goal is not to make the spine rigid.
It is to create more options.
Hypermobility At The Hip
Hip hypermobility can be particularly deceptive.
A client may:
sit in deep stretches comfortably
rotate the hips extensively
perform splits
drop into deep lunges
achieve huge ranges in side-lying work
Yet they may struggle with:
pelvic control
single-leg stability
hip endurance
gluteal strength
joint confidence
These clients often benefit from training the hip through controlled mid-range and progressive end-range strength, rather than repeatedly moving deeper into passive positions.
Proprioception Matters
One of the biggest issues for some hypermobile clients is reduced proprioception.
Proprioception is your body's awareness of where a joint is in space.
When a joint moves through a very large range, the client may have difficulty sensing where neutral or controlled mid-range actually is.
They may only recognise:
fully locked
fully stretched
fully extended
Intermediate positions can feel unfamiliar.
This is where slow, controlled Pilates work can be extremely useful.
Not because Pilates is inherently "gentle", but because it provides repeated opportunities
to develop better joint awareness under load.
Stability Does Not Mean Rigidity
This is important.
When instructors hear "stability", they sometimes overcorrect and create stiffness.
They tell hypermobile clients to:
brace constantly
stay rigid
avoid end range forever
never lock out
never move deeply
That is not the goal.
Stability means control, not immobility.
A healthy joint should be able to move through its available range while maintaining muscular control.
For many hypermobile clients, the long-term goal is to safely reclaim end range with strength not avoid it permanently.
Why End-Range Strength Matters
One of the biggest mistakes is keeping hypermobile clients forever in tiny ranges.
While early-stage control work may begin in mid-range, long-term programming should eventually include strength near end range.
Why?
Because the client lives in that range anyway.
If their shoulder naturally moves further than average, avoiding that range completely does not teach them how to control it.
Progression might include:
slower movement
supported end range
partial resistance
gradual load increases
controlled holds
The aim is to build ownership of the range they already have.
Slow Tempo Can Help
Tempo is extremely useful for hypermobile clients.
Fast movement can allow momentum to replace control.
Slowing an exercise down gives the nervous system more time to organise the joint position.
For example:
slow footwork
controlled lunges
slow shoulder loading
deliberate plank transitions
can improve awareness and reduce the tendency to collapse into end range.
Tempo becomes both a strength and motor-control tool.
Closed-Chain Work Can Be Valuable
Closed-chain exercises involve the hand or foot being fixed against a surface.
Examples include:
footwork
squats
planks
quadruped
standing exercises
These positions often provide greater proprioceptive input and can help hypermobile clients develop joint awareness.
That does not mean closed-chain is always superior.
It simply gives instructors another useful option when building control.
Progressive Resistance Is Essential
Hypermobile clients are often underloaded because instructors are afraid of irritating their joints.
This can be counterproductive.
If the client is always kept on the lightest spring with low challenge, they may never develop the strength required to support their range.
Progressive resistance helps improve:
joint stability
muscle endurance
confidence
load tolerance
proprioception
The key is dosage.
Load should be gradually increased based on the client's response, not avoided indefinitely.
Fatigue Changes Joint Control
This is especially important.
A hypermobile client may demonstrate excellent control for the first few repetitions.
As fatigue increases, they may begin:
locking knees
hanging into elbows
collapsing into lumbar extension
losing scapular control
This tells you something useful.
It means their current strength or endurance has reached its limit.
Rather than repeatedly cueing them through another fifteen poor-quality repetitions, stop the set.
Recover.
Then repeat.
This is better programming.
Why "Don't Lock Out" Is Not Enough
Many hypermobile clients have heard:
"Don't lock your knees."
"Don't hang into your elbows."
"Stay out of end range."
These instructions can create fear without building capacity.
Instead of only telling clients what not to do, give them an alternative strategy.
For example:
Instead of:"Don't lock your knee."
Try:"Keep a small amount of active tension through the front and back of the leg."
Instead of:"Don't hang into your elbows."
Try:"Press the carriage away and keep the arms active."
The goal is active control, not avoidance.
When Hypermobility Requires Referral
Pilates instructors do not diagnose hypermobility disorders.
Referral to a physiotherapist or appropriate health professional is recommended when a client presents with:
recurrent joint dislocations
significant pain
unexplained instability
repeated soft tissue injuries
neurological symptoms
symptoms affecting daily function
systemic concerns outside instructor scope
Some clients may have generalised joint hypermobility or connective tissue conditions requiring broader assessment.
Your role is to recognise when the presentation exceeds the scope of a Pilates class.
Programming Principles For Hypermobile Clients
A strong approach may include:
Start With Control
Build confidence through mid-range movements.
Use Slow Tempo
Reduce momentum and increase proprioceptive awareness.
Build Strength
Progress resistance gradually.
Train End Range Eventually
Do not permanently avoid the client's natural range.
Monitor Fatigue
Quality often declines before pain appears.
Avoid Excessive Passive Stretching
Especially where range is already excessive.
Use Closed-Chain Work
For added joint feedback where appropriate.
Progress To Functional Loading
The client should eventually be prepared for real-life demands, not just low-load studio work.
Practical Example: Hypermobile Shoulder In Plank
A client collapses into elbow hyperextension and loses scapular control.
Instead of repeatedly saying:
"Don't lock your elbows",
you could:
Shorten the plank duration.
Reduce the load.
Move to quadruped.
Build serratus and triceps strength.
Reintroduce plank gradually.
Increase hold time and resistance over time.
You are building the capacity needed for the task rather than only correcting the appearance.
Practical Example: Hypermobile Knees In Standing Work
A client stands with the knees locked backwards.
Try:
Cueing a soft but active knee.
Adding slight resistance.
Using controlled mini-squats.
Building calf and quadriceps endurance.
Progressing to single-leg balance.
Adding functional standing work.
Again, you are giving the client a stronger strategy rather than just removing the old one.
Professional Reflection
Hypermobile clients are often told they are "too flexible".
That description is incomplete.
The real issue is usually not the range itself.
It is whether they can control, load and trust that range.
Pilates can be incredibly valuable for hypermobile clients when programmed appropriately.
But if we keep giving them endless stretching, light springs and low challenge, we may actually reinforce the exact problem they need help solving.
The goal is not to make them less mobile.
The goal is to make them stronger inside the mobility they already have.
That is the difference between flexibility and function.
Key Teaching Takeaways
Hypermobility means increased joint range, not automatically dysfunction.
Hypermobile clients may still feel tight because of protective muscle tension.
More stretching is not always appropriate.
Stability means controlled movement, not rigidity.
Progressive resistance is essential for building joint support.
Slow tempo improves proprioception and control.
Closed-chain work can be useful for developing joint awareness.
Fatigue often reveals loss of control.
End range should eventually be strengthened, not avoided forever.
"Don't lock out" is not a complete coaching strategy.
Hypermobile clients need capacity, not permanent protection.
Referral is appropriate when symptoms exceed instructor scope.
Continue Building Your Clinical Reasoning
Working with hypermobile clients requires more than a list of precautions.
It requires understanding:
joint mechanics
load
motor control
proprioception
strength
fatigue
movement variability
The Advanced Injury Modification Certification through Body Form Education teaches
instructors how to work more confidently with musculoskeletal presentations while remaining within scope.
For instructors wanting a deeper understanding of why hypermobile joints behave the way they do, our Applied Anatomy & Biomechanics Certification explores joint mechanics, movement control and programming principles in far greater depth.
Both programmes are:
fully online
self-paced
available worldwide
no expiry
They are designed for Pilates instructors who want to move beyond memorised contraindications and build genuine clinical reasoning skills.
Comments